Keystone XL clears another hurdle but fight not over

The US State Department reported that it has no major environmental objections to TransCanada Corp’s Keystone XL pipeline, which would carry crude oil from Alberta more than 1,600 kilometres into America’s heartland. Though it does not recommend that the line be built, the State Department report, the Final Environmental Impact Statement, is seen by the pro-pipeline side as a big victory. Opponents, however, plan to step up their protests.

The report notes that the Canadian tar sands will be developed whether the US is on side with the pipeline or not. Other options for shipping the oil, including rail, trucks and barges, would be even worse for the environment, the report notes.

oil-pipeline-KeystoneXL-TransCanada-Barack-Obama-John-Kerry-Republicans-Boehner-Congress-EDIWeekly

Canada’s minister of natural resources, Joe Oliver, is urging President Obama to finally make his decision, though strictly speaking, it is not the president’s decision to make at this time. The pipeline has been under review for five years now. Five environmental impact studies have been done, Oliver noted, and each one has concluded that the pipeline would not adversely affect the environment. The concern among environmental groups on both sides of the border is that a spill from the pipeline could be devastating to the environment.

The Republicans in the US Congress are strongly in favour of Keystone. House Speaker John Boehner said today that the president must now “stand with the overwhelming majority of American people and approve this critical project.”

The head of the influential American Petroleum Institute, Jack Gerard, who has long championed the pipeline, said that the latest government review “puts to rest any credible concerns about the pipeline’s potential negative impact on the environment.” He called for the project to be “swiftly approved.”

It is not likely that approval will be swift, however. The State Department, headed by Senator John Kerry, must now consider input from a number of other government agencies, including the Environmental Protection Agency and both the Defence and Energy Departments. They will address issues of national security, as well as economic and environmental impacts. The public will also have a 30-day period in which to comment, beginning on February 5.

The president has said that he not approve Keystone unless it can be shown that it does not “significantly exacerbate the problem of carbon pollution.” While today’s announcement appears to satisfy that condition, the “problem of carbon pollution” is a very broad area. Some have argued that building the pipeline will only serve to perpetuate America’s dependence of “dirty oil,” which in itself could be interpreted as contributing to that problem.

Did you miss this?

Other Popular Stories

  • Airbus and Bombardier Finalize Deal
  • Bombardier has to delay CSeries first test flight again
  • Solar power companies report growth
  • Wood-based battery the next energy storage solution?
  • MRO continuing its rebound after Aveos collapse
  • Canada adopts ISO 20022 international electronic payment standard
  • SpaceX lost 40 satellites to solar storm, estimated cost of $10 to $20 million
  • NA clean energy goal of 50 per cent can't be met without nuclear, industry says
  • Solar Powered Cars — how practical is it; who is working on it; when is it coming? 5 companies profiled.
  • Honda expansion a win for Ontario's auto sector
  • NASA learns from the birds for the next generation in “Smart” dynamic wing design
  • Irving Shipbuilding wins $2.3 billion icebreaker contract with navy
  • Manufacturing sales up in September but shadow of Trump looms over Canada
  • NASA says human Mars landing is feasible by 2030s
  • Elon Musk, the master of disruptive technology companies: his life, successes — and failures
  • Slower growth, need for new markets challenge Canada's oil producers
  • Regina refinery will reuse all water with GE wastewater technology
  • Continued strength in manufacturing in November: RBC
  • Manufacturing up again in October
  • Government wants to know what chemicals are used in fracking
Scroll to Top